From Aishwarya Rai to a more inclusive stage: Have beauty pageants evolved over the years?

Aishwarya Rai, Miss World 1994: From Aishwarya Rai's 1994 Miss World victory to today's inclusive pageants, how much have beauty standards changed, and what remains unchanged?

inscript
7 min read
From Aishwarya Rai to a more inclusive stage: Have beauty pageants evolved over the years?

On 19 November 1994, a 21-year-old Aishwarya Rai brought the Miss World crown home to India. The win at Sun City, South Africa, became a defining moment in India's pageant history. More than three decades on, the date offers a chance to look beyond the crown and ask a larger question: how much have beauty pageants really changed?

For years, international beauty competitions have sold the idea that a woman could represent an entire country through her beauty, personality and grace. But behind the glamour, expensive gowns and carefully choreographed appearances lay a system that often measured women against a narrow set of physical expectations.

Today, the rules are changing. Married women and mothers can now take part, age restrictions have been eased, and contestants of different backgrounds and body types are getting opportunities that were once hard to imagine. Yet the bigger question remains: have beauty pageants moved beyond judging women by their appearance, or have they merely found new ways to present the same industry?

Where did beauty pageants begin?

The history of modern international beauty pageants is closely tied to advertising and entertainment.

In 1921, the first Miss America competition was held in Atlantic City, New Jersey. It started as a publicity effort to draw tourists to the seaside resort after the summer season. The competition was essentially a bathing beauty contest, in which women were judged on their appearance.

Miss World followed in 1951. British entrepreneur Eric Morley organised an event called the Festival Bikini Contest as part of the Festival of Britain celebrations. It was meant to promote the recently introduced bikini. The media began calling the competition Miss World, and the name eventually became official.

The inaugural Miss World contest was held on 29 July 1951 at the Lyceum Ballroom in London, drawing 27 contestants. Kerstin Håkansson of Sweden claimed the first title.

These origins matter because they shed light on the commercial basis of the pageant industry. Women were put on a stage, their looks turned into a spectacle, and the audience was asked to choose who embodied the ideal woman.

As time went on, these contests grew into international entertainment spectacles. Television carried them into millions of homes, and sponsors, fashion labels and advertisers helped transform contestants into widely recognised public figures.

When beauty became a target of protest

Criticism of beauty pageants dates back almost as far as the competitions themselves.

One of the most notable moments occurred on 7 September 1968, when feminist activists staged a protest outside the Miss America pageant in Atlantic City.

Organised by the New York Radical Women, the demonstration challenged how women were judged by their physical appearance. The protesters contended that the competition strengthened unrealistic ideals of femininity and turned women into objects of public scrutiny.

They further condemned the racial discrimination linked to the pageant. The competition had long excluded Black women, and it was not until 1970 that the first Black contestant took part in Miss America.

The protest became well known for its 'Freedom Trash Can', into which demonstrators tossed bras, high heels, make-up and other items they linked to restrictive beauty standards.

Despite popular belief, the protesters did not actually burn their bras. Media coverage helped foster that misleading impression.

The demonstration was not merely about rejecting make-up or challenging the notion of beauty. It was about questioning why women had to satisfy specific physical expectations in order to gain public recognition.

The protests also brought a contradiction to light. Pageants wanted contestants to look attractive while also seeming respectable, confident, intelligent and approachable. They were supposed to be glamorous without seeming overly provocative, and ambitious without coming across as intimidating.

These expectations turned beauty competitions into part of a far broader discussion about how society judges women.

From physical appearance to purpose and personality

As criticism mounted, pageants started to alter their formats and public image.

Miss World launched its Beauty with a Purpose initiative in 1972. The programme encouraged contestants to engage in humanitarian and social causes. Over the years, charitable projects grew into an important part of the competition's identity.

The aim was to present contestants as more than just attractive faces. Their community work, personal experiences and ability to advocate for social issues became part of their public profiles.

Miss World also distanced itself from its original bikini-focused format. It dropped its swimsuit round in 2014, signalling a shift in how it wished to present the competition.

Miss America took a different but no less significant step in 2018. After years of criticism and internal controversies, the organisation announced that it would scrap its swimsuit competition. It also stopped judging contestants on their evening wear.

The organisation stated that it wanted to focus on contestants' achievements, ambitions, talents and social impact initiatives.

These changes were significant. Yet removing a swimsuit round or adding charity projects does not by itself remove the influence of conventional beauty standards. Contestants still take part in a highly visual competition in which presentation, grooming, styling and stage presence remain important.

The question is whether the emphasis has truly shifted, or whether appearance still influences the outcome in less obvious ways.

Married women and mothers are no longer excluded

Possibly one of the most significant developments in the pageant industry relates to women's personal lives.

For many years, major international competitions upheld eligibility rules that barred married women and mothers. Contestants were required to be unmarried and without children, and certain rules obligated winners to stay unmarried throughout their reign.

As a result, a woman's marital status and whether she was a mother could decide if she was even permitted to take part.

In August 2022, Miss Universe revealed a significant change. Starting with its 2023 edition, married women and mothers were permitted to compete.

The change took aim at an outdated belief that a woman could not represent an international organisation while also being a wife or mother.

Miss World has likewise shifted towards permitting married women and mothers to take part, broadening the eligibility criteria that had traditionally limited contestants.

The importance extends beyond simply raising the number of eligible participants. It acknowledges that a woman's identity does not stop at marriage or motherhood. Her personal decisions should not automatically rule her out of professional opportunities.

Another notable change occurred in September 2023, when Miss Universe announced that its upper age limit had been removed. Before this, contestants were required to be between 18 and 28. Under the updated policy, women aged 18 and above were able to compete.

This opened the competition to women who had previously been excluded merely because they had passed a certain age.

Are different bodies finally getting representation?

For a long period, beauty pageants were tied to a comparatively narrow physical ideal. Height, measurements, facial features and a specific body type frequently shaped public ideas of how a beauty queen should look.

Yet recent editions have started to challenge that image.

In 2023, Jane Dipika Garrett of Nepal made history at Miss Universe as the competition's first widely recognised plus-size contestant. She made it into the Top 20, bringing international attention to the issue of body representation.

Her participation mattered because it questioned the idea that only one specific body type could belong on an international beauty stage.

That same edition also included Marina Machete of Portugal and Rikkie Kolle of the Netherlands, the first openly transgender women to compete in Miss Universe.

These developments mirrored a wider shift in how the pageant industry understands eligibility and representation.

Still, representation should not be mistaken for full acceptance. A contestant's presence on stage does not automatically mean the industry has stopped promoting conventional beauty ideals. Likewise, including a single plus-size contestant does not prove that contestants of different body types have equal opportunities throughout the competition.

Opening the door is not the same as changing the standards by which people are judged once they enter.

Have beauty pageants really changed?

The honest answer is yes, but not entirely.

Today's pageant industry is not the same as the one that emerged in the 1950s. Married women and mothers are now able to compete in major international competitions. Age restrictions have been altered. Transgender contestants have taken part, and contestants who do not fit traditional body expectations are gaining greater visibility.

There is also more focus on social causes, public speaking, leadership and individual achievements.

Yet beauty remains at the heart of the business.

Even when a swimsuit round is dropped, contestants are still expected to present themselves according to the competition's standards of grooming, styling, elegance and stage presence. The industry continues to operate within a culture in which appearance draws attention, sponsorships and public interest.

There is also a difference between celebrating diversity and letting women exist without having to prove they are beautiful, confident or inspiring.

Perhaps the biggest question is not whether beauty pageants should disappear, or whether they have become fully progressive. It is about whether women can take part without being expected to embody a particular standard of femininity.

Three decades on from Aishwarya Rai's win

When Aishwarya Rai won Miss World in 1994, it was an era in which international pageants held immense cultural weight. For India, her victory brought international recognition and helped make her a household name.

Since that time, the industry has changed considerably. Its contestants are increasingly portrayed as entrepreneurs, activists, professionals, mothers and advocates, rather than merely women vying for a crown.

Yet the legacy of how it began cannot be separated from its present.

Beauty pageants may have broadened their definition of an eligible woman, but they are still working out their relationship with beauty itself.

Perhaps progress should not be measured solely by how many different women are permitted to walk onto the stage. It should also be measured by how far the industry is prepared to move away from the notion that a woman's worth must be assessed, ranked and crowned in the first place.

Thirty-two years after Aishwarya Rai won Miss World, the crown remains. What is changing is the kind of woman the industry is willing to place beneath it. Whether that change goes deep enough is still an open question.

Written by
inscript
inscript
18 Followers

Read more

My Gaze: What stories unfold in Aparna Sen’s first photography book and solo exhibition?

Aparna Sen's 'My Gaze': A new artistic journey unfolds beyond celluloid with My Gaze, a photography collection spanning five decades, featuring photographs and personal recollections by Aparna Sen. The coffee table book carries a foreword by eminent poet and lyricist Javed Akhtar.

Protecting performing bodies A review of prACTice: A Living Journal for Actors + Artists

A review of prACTice: A Living Journal for Actors + Artists, exploring exploitation, consent, trauma and safety in the performing arts. It highlights the need to protect performers’ bodies, dignity and creative freedom through 50 powerful principles of self-empowerment and resistance.

Ramayana: Can a Rs. 4,000 crore 3D spectacle take Indian cinema to the global stage?

The two-part Ramayana aims to set a new benchmark for Indian cinema through advanced 3D technology, Hollywood-style virtual production and world-class visual effects. With a reported budget of Rs. 4,000 crore, the ambitious project hopes to take Indian cinema to a global audience.

Do recurring attacks on Christian community point to a growing pattern of religious intolerance in West Bengal?

Christians Under Attack in West Bengal: Amid allegations of disrupted prayers, attacks on churches and harassment over religious conversions in West Bengal, concerns are growing over religious freedom, vigilante groups, majoritarian politics and administrative inaction.

Rajnarayan, religion and colonial modernity in Nineteenth Century Bengal

This essay examines Rajnarayan Basu’s complex engagement with Hinduism, Enlightenment modernity and colonial subjugation in nineteenth-century Bengal. It traces how religious reform, intellectual enquiry and the textualization of culture shaped his understanding of Hindu identity, while tracing his contribution to cultural nationalism, Hindu revivalism and the search for an alternative, non-Western modernity.

“No fear, No fear!” How Diwali night turned into a nightmare for children with Autism

impact of noise pollution on children with autism: The incessant bursting of firecrackers during Diwali turned the festival nights into fear-inducing experiences for children with autism. Veteran disability rights activist from Bengal, Shampa Sengupta, writes about the sensory distress, medical challenges and difficulties faced by children with autism and other disabilities and the anxiety of their families during the festivities.

Kukur Tihar and Diwali: The precarious in-betweenness of dogs

Kukur Tihar, Diwali: While Nepal honours its dogs with marigold garlands and ritual offerings, India's Diwali celebrations expose a troubling contradiction. Illegal firecrackers leave dogs, cats and birds terrified, raising questions about animal welfare and whether compassion extends beyond religious rituals.