Bilkis Bano case: Why has the Supreme Court granted bail to two convicts despite their life sentences?
Bilkis Bano case: The Bilkis Bano case returns to the spotlight as the Supreme Court grants bail to two convicts serving life sentences.
The Bilkis Bano case has been one of the most followed cases in Indian criminal law since its start in 2002. It started with a young pregnant woman surviving communal riots in Gujarat, but now has become a landmark case with key developments such as a CBI investigation, the trial being moved out of state, 11 life sentences being given, a controversial remission order and an intervention from the Supreme Court.
On the 16th November 2026, it was confirmed that two of the eleven convicts had their life sentences suspended by the Supreme Court. This has caused questions to be raised around the rights of the convicted to appeal and the victim to receive justice.
But why were the two men granted bail? Does this mean their life sentences have been cancelled? And how did the case reach this stage?
What happened to Bilkis Bano in 2002?
To understand the case, we need to go back to February and March 2002. Following the burning of the Sabarmati Express in Godhra on the 27th February 2002, communal riots erupted throughout Gujarat. On the 3rd March 2002, Bilkis Bano, who was 21 years old then and 5 months pregnant fled her village of Randhikpur in Dahod district with members of her family.
The group was targeted by a mob near Pannivel. Bilkis was gang r*ped and seven members of her family, including her three year old daughter, were killed. Members of her extended family were also targeted.
The incident was not simply a case of communal violence. It became a case about the alleged involvement of local police officials, the failure of the initial investigation and the difficulties faced by a survivor seeking justice.
How did the investigation begin to fail?
The first FIR was lodged at Limkheda police station on the 4th March 2002. However, this did not include any information about the rape or the accused. Despite Bilkis identifying multiple people.
In November 2002, the police handed in a closure report stating that whilst the case was true, they could not identify any culprits. Initially, the court requested further investigation but the second closure report was accepted in February 2003.
However, Bilkis refused to give up.
She appealed to the Supreme Court in April 2003, asking for a fresh investigation. On the 6th December 2003 the Supreme Court ordered the investigation to be moved to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI).
The CBI investigated and charged 20 people including 6 police officers and 2 doctors with being involved in mishandling the investigation and post mortems. During the investigation, serious issues were found regarding the identification of the victims.
Why was the trial moved to Maharashtra?
As Bilkis had concerns around threats and not receiving a fair trial in Gujarat, the Supreme Court moved the trial to Mumbai in August 2004 to ensure a fair and impartial trial.
On the 21st January 2008, 11 men were convicted by a special CBI court in Mumbai for offences including rape and murder and were sentenced to life imprisonment.
7 people were acquitted whilst 2 of the accused had died during the trial.
However, these convictions were challenged. In May 2017 the Bombay High Court upheld the convictions and life sentences for all 11 men. They also overturned the acquittals of 5 police officers and 2 doctors, finding them guilty of offences related to mishandling the investigation.
Finally, convictions had been made.
The 2022 Controversy: Why were all 11 convicts released?
On the 15th August 2022, the Gujarat Government granted all 11 convicts a remission under their 1992 Remission Policy.
Remission is an act legally allowing the government to reduce a sentence length or early release a prisoner. This does not mean they have been acquitted.
This came after an order from the Supreme Court on the 13th May 2022 requesting the Gujarat Government to consider a remission request from one of the convicts, Radheshyam Shah. The request was under the Remission Policy applicable to him at the time of his conviction.
The Gujarat Government agreed to release all 11 men. They left Godhra sub-jail on the 15th August 2022.
This led to much controversy. Particularly as there were reports of them being greeted with sweets and garlands.
Bilkis appealed to the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court Quashes the Remission on 8th January 2024.
The Supreme Court ruled on the 8th January 2024 that the remission orders from the Gujarat Government were quashed.
Justices BV Nagarathna and Ujjal Bhuyan ruled that the Gujarat Government were not the correct Government to make the remission decision.
Since the trial was moved to Mumbai, and the men were convicted by a court in Maharashtra, the Supreme Court ruled that the Maharashtra Government should have considered the remission under section 432 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
They also ruled that there were serious legal issues with the process. Saying the Gujarat Government had gone beyond their jurisdiction and not taken into consideration the relevant facts, including the opinion of the trial judge. The court ruled that the 11 convicts must surrender within 2 weeks.
They returned to prison in January 2024.
Crucially, their convictions were not overturned by the Supreme Court. However, the remission orders that led to their early release were cancelled.
Why have 2 convicts been given bail by the Supreme Court?
On the 28th October 2026, Justices MM Sundresh and Prasanna B Varale ruled that the life sentences of 2 of the convicts, Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya would be suspended. This was uploaded recently and reported on the 16th November.
The 2 men had appealed to the Supreme Court regarding the May 2017 judgement from the Bombay High Court which upheld their convictions and life sentences.
The court took into account 3 key points.
Both men had been in jail for over 17 years.
One of the men had a severe physical disability.
The appeals contained issues of fact and law that needed to be looked into.
The defence had also argued that one of the men had not been named in the original FIR and had been implicated almost 3 years after the incident.
The prosecution opposed the bail requests. Arguing that they had committed serious offences and had been convicted by the courts.
However, following their submissions, the Supreme Court ruled that their sentences would be suspended and they would be given bail. With conditions to be set by the relevant trial court.
Their appeals will be heard in due course. Do they no longer have to serve their life sentences?
No! This is perhaps the most important point to take away from this news.
The men were released in 2022 due to the remission order. This meant they were released early due to a government order. However, this was quashed by the Supreme Court in 2024.
The latest order is different.
The 2 men have been given bail whilst their appeals are still outstanding. Their sentences have been suspended meaning their life sentences have been paused whilst the Supreme Court look into their appeals.
Their convictions have not been overturned.
If the Supreme Court uphold their convictions and sentences they may have to return to prison. Depending on the final ruling. The other 9 convicts have not been given the same relief. They will have to look into their own legal options.
What has Bilkis Bano said?
On the 17th November 2026, Bilkis expressed her shock and disappointment with the bail order. She questioned why the decision had been made without her being able to give her opinion and said she would be appealing.
This raises the important question of how the justice system balances the legal rights of the convicted and the victim.
Whilst the legal process allows the convicted to appeal their convictions and have their sentences suspended whilst they appeal, the victim has legal interests in the case. As this has shown, it is important they are given the chance to have their say.
A case still not over
The Bilkis Bano case has gone through many stages of the justice system in India. It has shown issues with the investigation, the need for an impartial trial and raised concerns around the use of remission.
In 2024 the Supreme Court ruled that the 11 convicts should return to prison as the decision to grant remission was legally invalid. However, the bail order in 2026 adds a new twist to the case.
For the 2 men it is a legal remedy for their appeals. For Bilkis it is another twist in a case that has lasted over 2 decades.
Overall, this raises the question of how the justice system can protect the rights of the victims whilst ensuring all accused have the right to appeal their convictions. Over 24 years after the incident, the final chapter of the Bilkis Bano case has yet to be written.

