If the Left has 'zero relevance' why does the right keep returning to it?

A red flag burned inside a university campus. Days earlier, the Prime Minister warned of 'dimaagi Naxals' who, he said, must be 'identified and isolated'. In between these moments lies a question larger than the mob attack and violence in Jadavpur University: when dissent, Left politics and student mobilisation are repeatedly cast as threats, what exactly is being fought—and why?

inscript
5 min read
If the Left has 'zero relevance' why does the right keep returning to it?

What does it mean when a political force that has been declared electorally irrelevant by the right wing still provokes such intense political mobilisation?

At Jadavpur University, a dispute over a student general body meeting escalated on Wednesday night into allegations of assault, vandalism, arson and attempts to attack students. The immediate dispute involved the Faculty of Engineering and Technology Students’ Union (FETSU) meeting, whose validity ABVP questioned. ABVP alleged that its supporters were attacked and subjected to casteist remarks; Left student organisations, meanwhile, alleged that ABVP and RSS-linked groups brought outsiders into the campus. Several students were injured and police entered the university to contain the situation.

But the more revealing part of the episode may lie beyond the immediate confrontation. Left organisations have provided solid evidence that their flags were torn and burnt and that parts of the campus were vandalised with abusive slurs being hurled upon students. Politically, however, the behaviour is difficult to ignore. A red flag is not an electoral seat. Why, then, does it continue to generate such hostility? So much so that the same groups labeling left politics irrelevant, feel the need to sneak in outsiders into a university campus to attack and abuse students allegedly participating in left leaning politics?

Jadavpur has long been one of Bengal’s most politically charged university spaces. The latest confrontation also comes against a history of repeated clashes around attempts by the ABVP and the broader Hindutva camp to establish a presence on a campus associated with Left student politics. In 2019, ABVP-linked mobilisation at JU was accompanied by allegations of vandalism and arson, while the BJP subsequently described the university as an anti-national hub.

This pattern has today become the battleground which is not simply electoral. Universities produce political language of dissent, organisations and young cadres. They turn questions of employment, examinations, education, inequality and state power into collective action. The recent student mobilisation around examination irregularities, including the protests involving student unions like AISA demonstrates that Left student politics can still occupy that space even when the electoral Left is deeply weakened.

That is also why the language used against dissent deserves scrutiny. On Independence Day, Prime Minister Narendra Modi used the term dimaagi Naxals, distinguishing them from armed Naxalism while warning that such ideological influence remained a threat. Union minister Kiren Rijiju subsequently said the phrase referred to people supporting Maoists and separatists, not Opposition leaders. Yet the political reaction exposed how easily Naxal can migrate from a historically specific armed movement aginst exploitation into a much broader vocabulary for describing ideological opponents.

That shift matters in Bengal, where the history of Naxalism also carries memories of radical student politics, class struggle and resistance to entrenched power alongside the violence of the movement itself. Reducing that complicated history to a synonym for terrorism erases the political argument embedded within it.

None of this makes the Left electorally powerful. Perhaps that is precisely the contradiction worth examining. If the Left has genuinely ceased to matter, why must its flags still be burnt, its symbols contested, its student politics repeatedly confronted and its ideological vocabulary repeatedly invoked as a threat?

The question is not whether the Left can return to power tomorrow. It is why a supposedly irrelevant political force continues to occupy so much space in the political imagination of its opponents.

Cover image : Debalina Mou

Written by
inscript
inscript
18 Followers

Read more

Protecting performing bodies A review of prACTice: A Living Journal for Actors + Artists

A review of prACTice: A Living Journal for Actors + Artists, exploring exploitation, consent, trauma and safety in the performing arts. It highlights the need to protect performers’ bodies, dignity and creative freedom through 50 powerful principles of self-empowerment and resistance.

Bilkis Bano case: Why has the Supreme Court granted bail to two convicts despite their life sentences?

Bilkis Bano case: The Bilkis Bano case returns to the spotlight as the Supreme Court grants bail to two convicts serving life sentences.

Ramayana: Can a Rs. 4,000 crore 3D spectacle take Indian cinema to the global stage?

The two-part Ramayana aims to set a new benchmark for Indian cinema through advanced 3D technology, Hollywood-style virtual production and world-class visual effects. With a reported budget of Rs. 4,000 crore, the ambitious project hopes to take Indian cinema to a global audience.

Narendra Modi's 25 years in public office: Impact on Indian politics

Narendra Modi's 25 years: Over the past 25 years, Indian politics has undergone significant changes in leadership, elections and governance. From the Gujarat Model to national leadership, this article explores Narendra Modi’s political journey and its impact on India's democratic and political landscape.

Do recurring attacks on Christian community point to a growing pattern of religious intolerance in West Bengal?

Christians Under Attack in West Bengal: Amid allegations of disrupted prayers, attacks on churches and harassment over religious conversions in West Bengal, concerns are growing over religious freedom, vigilante groups, majoritarian politics and administrative inaction.

Sonia Gandhi’s ‘Belonging’ creates a Harry Potter-like frenzy: What are booksellers saying?

Sonia Gandhi, Belonging A Journey of Love: Sonia Gandhi’s memoir sparks unprecedented excitement across India, with bookshops reporting impressive sales and readers comparing its popularity to Harry Potter.

Can COP31 turn climate promises into concrete action?

COP31 Climate Summit: The global climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, has brought climate finance, emission cuts and adaptation measures into focus. Delegates from nearly 200 countries are discussing concrete steps to address global warming and provide financial support to vulnerable nations.

Caught between two countries: Woman stranded at India-Bangladesh border for four days

Four days have passed, yet a woman remains stranded at the India-Bangladesh border, caught between two nations unwilling to claim her. Her ordeal raises troubling questions about identity, citizenship, border politics and the human cost of statelessness.