Trump-Modi bonhomie: When domestic political pressure brings two leaders closer

Donald Trump, Narendra Modi: Trump and Modi's public warmth comes amid domestic political challenges, raising questions about how personal diplomacy serves strategic and political interests.

inscript
4 min read
Trump-Modi bonhomie: When domestic political pressure brings two leaders closer

After they met at the Quad summit in Manila on 17 November, Donald Trump has spoken openly of his admiration for Narendra Modi. He called Modi a ‘great leader’ and a ‘great friend’. Trump also said Modi is ‘highly respected’ around the world and described him as a 'very tough man'.

Why it matters?

Right now, both Trump and Modi are dealing with tough political situations at home.

Trump suffered a major political defeat after the mid-term elections on 3 November. The Democrats took control of both the House of Representatives and the Senate. Many read the result as a clear rejection of Trump’s political policies.

The reasons include the high cost of living, worries about inflation, frustration with how the administration handled the conflict with Iran, and concerns about governance.

Because of this, Trump now faces a harder political situation. With the Democrats controlling the House and the Senate, Trump’s administration may find it difficult to push through parts of his political agenda. The opposition can challenge some administration decisions, launch investigations, and subject government decisions to closer scrutiny.

Still, this does not mean Trump has lost his authority as President. The balance of power in Congress has shifted because of the mid-term results, but the President still holds considerable actual power.

Even so, Trump’s political position has clearly weakened as he heads into the second half of his Presidency. His administration will face far greater scrutiny.

Domestic challenges facing Modi

Narendra Modi is also up against difficult circumstances at home. The Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls has stirred up considerable controversy. Opposition parties argue that the process run by the Election Commission could wrongly strip voters of their rights and that it lacks transparency.

On 1 November, a big crowd of opposition supporters gathered in Delhi, demanding that Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar step down. The protest, led by Rahul Gandhi, shows how widely the changes to electoral rolls are being opposed.

The issue has turned into a major point of friction inside the BJP, especially since it has drawn heavy media coverage in West Bengal.

There are clear political pressures at play here, but the Indian Government and the BJP-led administration remain stable. The next general elections are not scheduled until 2029.

So while Modi faces mounting political challenges, his position as Prime Minister is not under immediate threat. Still, doubts about the election's legitimacy are growing, the opposition is mobilising more, and government decisions are being viewed negatively.

International recognition can work in Modi's favour. It presents India as a global power and shows that Modi has strong ties abroad.

Why this meeting matters (beyond just a friendly relationship)

This meeting was not simply a one-on-one between Trump and Modi. It was part of the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue (Quad), which brings together India, the USA, Japan and Australia.

First set up in 2007, the group was revived in 2017 during Trump's first term. It was formed to enable cooperation among member nations in the Indo-Pacific region. The group came together to tackle shared concerns in the region. These include security worries, China's growing influence, and dependence on fragile supply chains.

The Quad summit on 17 November 2022 mattered because it was the first time Quad leaders had met in two years. Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi and Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese were also present.

The four nations unveiled several new initiatives:

Sharpening intelligence sharing and situational awareness across Indo-Pacific waters.

A combined naval drill in 2027, drawing in surveillance aircraft from all four countries.

The first-ever Quad Business Leaders' Forum, set for early 2027.

Closer cooperation on fronts such as AI and cyber-security.

Tighter coordination on counter-terrorism efforts and critical supply chains.

These initiatives show the Quad has a genuinely strategic plan in place, moving well past mere goodwill among leaders.

For India, the grouping matters as a way to widen its influence in the Indo-Pacific without formally signing up to a military alliance. For the USA, India stands as a key regional partner in balancing Chinese power.

That makes the relationship especially important for both Trump and Modi. Whatever the political situation in each country right now, there is strategic value in keeping the cooperation going.

Not always a smooth relationship

Though Trump and Modi appear close, friction has crept into the India-USA relationship since Trump returned to the White House in January 2025.

Trade tensions were a major source of friction. In 2025, the USA piled further tariffs onto Indian goods, pushing the total tariff rate on them to 50%. Indian purchases of Russian oil were part of the reason behind the tariff hike.

Trump has also claimed a hand in bringing about the ceasefire after the military conflict between India and Pakistan in May 2025. New Delhi, however, denied that any third party had mediated the ceasefire.

That friction chipped away at political trust between the two countries.

Still, both sides have tried to mend the relationship. February 2026 brought a framework aimed at lowering the rate of retaliatory tariffs on Indian goods coming from the USA. The 25% tariff dropped to 18%, and the extra 25% duties slapped on Indian imports over Russian oil purchases were scrapped.

That is a major shift, and it shows the India–USA relationship does not rest on a personal bond alone. Talks have covered trade, energy, defence and regional security.

So even with friendly ties, competing national interests have to be weighed.

What does each leader gain from this public relationship?

This may be the most intriguing part of the relationship.

For Trump, keeping India on good terms pays off both strategically and economically. Washington sees India as a key Indo-Pacific partner thanks to cooperation on maritime security, technology and critical minerals.

After the mid-term results, it particularly suits Trump to show that his administration still holds key influential relationships abroad. Praising Modi and appearing close to him helps Trump do exactly that.

For Modi, a warm relationship with the American President matters a great deal.

As noted earlier, the USA is still seen as a key strategic partner for India. So a visible relationship with Trump shows India's influence on the world stage. It also shows that New Delhi still has lines to influential global leaders.

Finally, the relationship gives Modi a chance to keep diplomatic continuity going despite earlier disputes over trade and other bilateral issues.

Still, we have to separate the diplomatic gains for both leaders from the potential political ones.

No public evidence exists to indicate that Trump praised Modi to boost his own political standing in the USA, or that Modi was seeking validation from the American President to shore up his political position in India.

A more sensible reading is that both leaders gain from being seen together in public, since both governments are under scrutiny at home.

A survival tactic, or a strategic interest?

It may be tempting to read this meeting as each leader trying to win support from the other amid domestic political trouble, but we have to weigh the broader geopolitical context.

The USA has a strategic interest in keeping a strong relationship with India in the Indo-Pacific region. In the same way, India has a strategic interest in maintaining strong international ties to advance its economic, technological and security interests.

Both countries also have reason not to let disputes over trade, energy and regional conflicts damage their wider political relationship.

The personal bond between the two leaders can help keep political engagement between the countries alive, but it does not necessarily resolve the issues behind those disputes.

So the friendly public relationship between Trump and Modi carries two main significances. It shows the diplomatic interests between the two countries and lets both leaders draw political benefit from being seen with each other.

After the Quad summit in Manila, Trump and Modi put on a display of friendly relations. Both leaders are navigating difficult political circumstances. One is staring at electoral defeat and a strengthening opposition in Congress. The other faces continuing domestic criticism over electoral processes and growing opposition mobilisation.

Their situations differ, but neither faces an immediate threat to his position. Still, both have an incentive to show they maintain strong international relationships.

The key takeaway from this meeting is that personal diplomacy still matters in political relationships, even when complications emerge in domestic politics.

Whether this friendship will deliver long-term political or diplomatic benefits remains unclear. Still, it hands both leaders a chance to show off their international clout, even as they deal with tough problems at home.

Written by
inscript
inscript
18 Followers

Read more

Protecting performing bodies A review of prACTice: A Living Journal for Actors + Artists

A review of prACTice: A Living Journal for Actors + Artists, exploring exploitation, consent, trauma and safety in the performing arts. It highlights the need to protect performers’ bodies, dignity and creative freedom through 50 powerful principles of self-empowerment and resistance.

Bilkis Bano case: Why has the Supreme Court granted bail to two convicts despite their life sentences?

Bilkis Bano case: The Bilkis Bano case returns to the spotlight as the Supreme Court grants bail to two convicts serving life sentences.

Ramayana: Can a Rs. 4,000 crore 3D spectacle take Indian cinema to the global stage?

The two-part Ramayana aims to set a new benchmark for Indian cinema through advanced 3D technology, Hollywood-style virtual production and world-class visual effects. With a reported budget of Rs. 4,000 crore, the ambitious project hopes to take Indian cinema to a global audience.

Narendra Modi's 25 years in public office: Impact on Indian politics

Narendra Modi's 25 years: Over the past 25 years, Indian politics has undergone significant changes in leadership, elections and governance. From the Gujarat Model to national leadership, this article explores Narendra Modi’s political journey and its impact on India's democratic and political landscape.

Do recurring attacks on Christian community point to a growing pattern of religious intolerance in West Bengal?

Christians Under Attack in West Bengal: Amid allegations of disrupted prayers, attacks on churches and harassment over religious conversions in West Bengal, concerns are growing over religious freedom, vigilante groups, majoritarian politics and administrative inaction.

Sonia Gandhi’s ‘Belonging’ creates a Harry Potter-like frenzy: What are booksellers saying?

Sonia Gandhi, Belonging A Journey of Love: Sonia Gandhi’s memoir sparks unprecedented excitement across India, with bookshops reporting impressive sales and readers comparing its popularity to Harry Potter.

Can COP31 turn climate promises into concrete action?

COP31 Climate Summit: The global climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, has brought climate finance, emission cuts and adaptation measures into focus. Delegates from nearly 200 countries are discussing concrete steps to address global warming and provide financial support to vulnerable nations.