Winkle Twinkle review: Can communism survive changing times?

Srijit Mukherji’s Winkle Twinkle examines whether communism can survive changing times, generations and political realities. Through Sabyasachi Sen’s return to a transformed world, the film explores ideological faith, political relevance, adaptation and the uneasy inheritance of political belief.

Aritrik Dutta Chowdhury
8 min read
Winkle Twinkle review: Can communism survive changing times?

What if Rip Van Winkle was born a communist? Is communism a political construct or an ideology? If it is an ideology, can it die out with time? Or does it rise like the phoenix with changing times, warding off skins and adorning newer ones. Every time it vanishes into thin air, does Banquo surmise:

“The earth hath bubbles, as the water has,

And these are of them. Whither are they vanished?” (Macbeth, Act I Scene III)

Bratya Basu, in his timeless play “Winkle Twinkle” had probed us into negotiations that question, endorse and negate such interventions. Performed by ace thespians like Debesh Chattopadhyay, Rajatava Dutta and other luminaries more than a decade ago; this play has been recently adapted into a film by Srijit Mukherjee where he not only contemporises the context but also nudges us further into the political debates of our times. Sabyasachi Sen, the protagonist (played by Ritwik Chakraborty) sublimates into thin air while being chased by the sleuths in the backdrop of 1976 Naxalite movement and is readily considered dead. The story is a revisit of Sabyasachi, who has presumably woken up from his slumber and sees the world through the Rip Van Winkle eye. In 2002, as he himself says: “Ei notun Din notun ‘ism’ er modhye ami misfit. Hoy khap khaiye nebo nahole morey jabo” (I am a misfit amidst this new times, new ‘isms’. Either I shall accommodate or silently pass away). His personality has always been political and his politics has always been very personal. He comes back to a time where he sees his political ideology ailing, a few of his communist friends established in bourgeois careers and the others exhibiting deranged manifestation of political allegiance.

The use of cinematic images is enticing. The metaphor of the lobster that comes as a narrative metacommentary in the film reinstates the idea of regeneration, repair and denying to wither with time that alludes to Sabyasachi. The father – son relationship goes beyond the personal as the cross – generational political and ideological battle is highlighted through the conversations. Indro, as the political doppelganger also holds a mirror in front of the indomitable, obdurate but redundant father. The fight that Srijit portrays is one between political relevance and political reverence. While a few motifs like the mass scale use of Frigidaire in 1976, and Keypad mobile phones, or invigoration pill ‘Shilajit’ in 2002 appear quite anachronistic; the background score of “Ek Akasher Neeche” harps the Bengali nostalgia aptly. The background conversation between Atul and his son in “Ek Akasher Neeche” is an interesting context to the main plot for which the director deserves an applause. The scene where Sabyasachi dumps the landline receiver and talks about the radio station quite simultaneously, is a wonderful juxtaposition that caters to the time travel and the changing modes of communication he is unable to adjust with. The role of Sabyasachi (Ritwik)’s wife played by Sohini Sarkar and Anasuya Majumder in two time zones were apt casting choices in my view. They are brilliant in their resemblance and depth, in kindling and restraining to make their performance credible. Parambrata Chattopadhyay as Indro deserves an applause.

The script and direction leave no stone unturned to establish communism as the most powerful mode of resistance through the changing times from 1976 through 2002 to 2025 and reinstates the eternal relevance of the ideology through the voice of the protagonist:

“Communism uthe jae ki kore, eta ekta motobad. Jotodin daridro ache, boishomyo ache, eta thakbe.” (How can communism lose its relevance! It is an ideology. As long as poverty and class differences prevail, communism shall prevail as well); yet it doesn’t fail to allude to the democracy of free – will and choice:

“Ideology alada hotei pare. Eta thakumar gopal thakur noy je sara jibon boye berate hobe!” (Ideology can be different. It is not a family heirloom being passed on as a burden that you need to carry around forever).

Srijit works wonders with his research and vision, but the USP of the film is definitely the script. While carefully bringing the cynic, the sceptic and the Epicurean into its purview when he makes his character say: “Kichu lok bhalo ache. Jader onyer bhalo thaka niye kichu jae ashe na, tara bhalo ache.” (Some people are happy. The ones who don’t care about others being happy are happy indeed); he also convinces his audience to acknowledge that one needs to adapt to the changing times and for an ideology to not die out, it is important to seep into the skin of the people and adopt, adapt and adeptly succumb to the transformation. The latest acceptance in the lines: “Somoy bodlechhey. Mathay kono chhata nei, songe kono shibir nei, samne kono michhil nei. Tai pokhyo nin.” (Times have changed. There’s no canopy over your head, no political camp beside you, no political rally in front of you. So, you must choose a side); also offers a proposal to the audience and insinuates at the need to be politically aware and risk a choice.

The ending of the film opens up avenues to further internal negotiations with an undying ideology that refuses to be annihilated yet denies accepting the pace at which the world changes. Besides being an answer to the magic real conundrum that the director successfully sustains through the film, the ending aptly proposes a political debate within communism and its wings and also between communism and various other political precepts that struggle hard to pass off an indispensable ideology.

Written by

Read more

Protecting performing bodies A review of prACTice: A Living Journal for Actors + Artists

A review of prACTice: A Living Journal for Actors + Artists, exploring exploitation, consent, trauma and safety in the performing arts. It highlights the need to protect performers’ bodies, dignity and creative freedom through 50 powerful principles of self-empowerment and resistance.

Bilkis Bano case: Why has the Supreme Court granted bail to two convicts despite their life sentences?

Bilkis Bano case: The Bilkis Bano case returns to the spotlight as the Supreme Court grants bail to two convicts serving life sentences.

Ramayana: Can a Rs. 4,000 crore 3D spectacle take Indian cinema to the global stage?

The two-part Ramayana aims to set a new benchmark for Indian cinema through advanced 3D technology, Hollywood-style virtual production and world-class visual effects. With a reported budget of Rs. 4,000 crore, the ambitious project hopes to take Indian cinema to a global audience.

Narendra Modi's 25 years in public office: Impact on Indian politics

Narendra Modi's 25 years: Over the past 25 years, Indian politics has undergone significant changes in leadership, elections and governance. From the Gujarat Model to national leadership, this article explores Narendra Modi’s political journey and its impact on India's democratic and political landscape.

Do recurring attacks on Christian community point to a growing pattern of religious intolerance in West Bengal?

Christians Under Attack in West Bengal: Amid allegations of disrupted prayers, attacks on churches and harassment over religious conversions in West Bengal, concerns are growing over religious freedom, vigilante groups, majoritarian politics and administrative inaction.

Sonia Gandhi’s ‘Belonging’ creates a Harry Potter-like frenzy: What are booksellers saying?

Sonia Gandhi, Belonging A Journey of Love: Sonia Gandhi’s memoir sparks unprecedented excitement across India, with bookshops reporting impressive sales and readers comparing its popularity to Harry Potter.

Can COP31 turn climate promises into concrete action?

COP31 Climate Summit: The global climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, has brought climate finance, emission cuts and adaptation measures into focus. Delegates from nearly 200 countries are discussing concrete steps to address global warming and provide financial support to vulnerable nations.

Caught between two countries: Woman stranded at India-Bangladesh border for four days

Four days have passed, yet a woman remains stranded at the India-Bangladesh border, caught between two nations unwilling to claim her. Her ordeal raises troubling questions about identity, citizenship, border politics and the human cost of statelessness.